You’ve Got a Friend
Mar. 25th, 2023 12:07 pmAnd you need some loving care.
And nothing, nothing is going right.
Close your eyes and think of me,
And soon I will be there.
To brighten up even your darkest night.
You just call out my name,
And you know, wherever I am,
I’ll come running,
To see you again.
Winter, spring, summer, or fall,
All you have to do is call,
And I’ll be there.
You’ve got a friend.
(You’ve Got a Friend: Carole King – 1971)
Belated news of a loved one’s death has always been an unbalancing experience for me. It’s not shocking, like a sudden, unforeseen, or accidental death tends to be. Rather, these deaths are hard to believe or accept, because they occurred months or a year before – when you still thought that person was alive and well. Such was the case when my wife Kathleen, while perusing the monthly Associates newsletter from the Congregation of Sisters of St. Joseph Carondelet (CSJ), learned of the death of Carol Ann Krommer last December. More than a month had passed since her actual death, and during that time we had sent Carol a Christmas card, and wondered if we would speak to her by phone. All those well-meaning thoughts and intentions were now meaningless. Carol was dead, and we’d never again see her, speak with her, recall experiences we shared, or laugh about days long past. A part of our lives had died with her.
On Saturday, February 18th, a cold and gloomy morning, Kathy and I drove up to Mission San Buenaventura, in Ventura, to attend Carol’s funeral Mass. Despite our original disequilibrium at the belated news, there was never a doubt that we would both attend. Carol was a personal friend to each of us – since Kathy’s student days at Mount St. Mary’s College in 1968, and my first teaching days at St. Bernard High School in 1972. Yet we both entered the Mission courtyard with a certain amount of apprehension. So many years had passed since we’d had actual contact with Carol, her sisters, or any of her friends, I feared I wouldn’t know anyone at the funeral. It wasn’t until I recognized Carol’s sister Judy (who had taught with me at St. Bernard H.S.) walking slowly up to the pulpit to give the eulogy before the beginning of mass that I relaxed and calmly listened to her tales of growing up with Carol.

I’m bad at processing my feelings at emotional moments. It took a few weeks after the funeral before I felt sufficiently settled to write down my own thoughts and memories of Carol. My ideas centered on three clear images and scenes of Carol: as a caring, talented, and charismatic teacher, and an extraordinary guidance counselor to students and beginning teachers; as a verbal champion for Fairness, Christian Charity, and Justice; and, finally, as a determined, matchmaking friend who would risk giving relational advice.
I was first introduced to Carol by Marilyn Rudy in the faculty lounge of St. Bernard High School in January of 1972. They were both nuns in the Congregation of St. Joseph of Carondelet (CSJ), and Sister Marilyn was my Department Chair. I had been hired to teach U.S. History without any prior teaching experience. I obviously interviewed well enough with the Principal, Father Larry Dunphy, to allay any fears or misgivings he or Marilyn had about my lack of training and experience. I certainly felt confident at the time of the interview – but that feeling was fast eroding as the day to my first interactions with students approached. The first year of teaching is always difficult, but doing so without any prior training or practice is almost suicidal. Although most veteran teachers are usually responsive to appeals for assistance, many tend to shy away from unschooled rookies so as not to witness the train wrecks occurring in their classrooms. In those tenuous first months, Sister Marilyn graciously and generously stepped into the role of mentor and advisor. She paired me with another young and talented Social Studies teacher, Jerry Lenhard, to act as a model and guide, and introduced me to Carol. At first, I simply accepted her as Marilyn’s friend. It was only later I realized that Carol was the third member of the triumvirate that Marilyn created to support and sustain me during my first difficult semester of teaching.


Sister Carol (as I knew her then) was the Religion Department Chair and school guidance counselor. She was clearly a close friend of Marilyn. They lived in community with 4 to 6 other CSJ nuns in a converted apartment house across the street from St. Anastasia Church, near the high school. I remember her as tall, with a smiling angular face, and a delightful laugh. More importantly she was a great listener. It became clear, as Marilyn, Jerry, Carol, and I got together at Nutrition and Lunch in the faculty lounge, that Carol’s presence was to provide me with solace and encouragement, while Marilyn and Jerry gave me curricular techniques and strategies. General conversation and laughter were also a large part of those times together, as well as chagrined amusement at some of my well-intentioned instructional gaffes and disasters. However, Carol was never my exclusive counselor. Countless teachers and staff members would seek her out, or join our lunch table, to speak about students, classes, or themselves. She always had a ready ear and a sympathetic heart. Through the efforts of this trio, I survived my first year of teaching.

The following year (1972-73), I was a much more confident and knowledgeable teacher. I enjoyed teaching and interacting with students, and I made new friends among the faculty. My relationships with Carol and Marilyn also developed into a sincere and personal friendship. I could talk to Carol about anything, and I was soon a regular member at the Friday evening TGIF parties that the CSJ’s hosted at their convent. Besides the joking and laughter at these get-togethers, I also learned of the CSJ’s commitment to social justice and charity. Carol and this community of nuns looked beyond a life dedicated to prayer and teaching, and they saw themselves as active participants and implementers of Christ’s teachings in the Gospel. Carol also dared to speak out about the institutional inconsistencies in the decisions and actions of School and Church authorities.
In the early days of 1973, an issue arose that would normally have been dealt with privately by the principal, Father Dunphy. However, Larry was the rare priest and leader who not only sought out the advice of nuns on his administrative staff and faculty but also was also unafraid to discuss crucial matters openly in a professional forum. The case involved a very popular and intelligent student who became pregnant during the summer before her junior year. She decided to keep the baby and raise it at home with her parents and returned to school to finish the year. Her desire to finish high school was lauded by all, and her decision to have the baby was cited as the proper Catholic choice, in a time when teenage abortions were so prevalent. The dilemma arose however when the unwed mother-student applied as a candidate for the office of Student Body President. The issue became an immediate cause célèbre in the faculty lunchroom, where scandalized teachers and priests demanded her disqualification for violating the Student Code of Conduct. They believed that all candidates for student government office, especially the presidency, should be models of Catholic values, morals, and behavior, and an unwed, teenaged mother clearly failed to reach that standard. I like to believe that it was the gradual and subtle influence of the CSJ’s on Larry Dunphy, who was a regular TGIF guest at their apartment, that convinced him to discuss this issue in a special faculty meeting before making his decision. The afterschool forum gave teachers and staff a chance to speak their minds and listen to the opinions of others, but it wasn’t until Sister Carol spoke that we were finally forced to view the issue as honest Catholics and faithful followers of Christ. She galvanized the room by quietly and solemnly relating the story that, as Guidance Counselor, she knew of students who had secretly terminated unwanted pregnancies, and had run for, and been elected to, student body offices.
“What message are we sending as a Catholic school,” she asked, “when we penalize a pregnant student for publicly doing the right thing of giving birth to her child, while rewarding students who secretly have abortions?”

It was the uncomfortable question that no one wanted to hear. Without ever quoting scripture or making comparisons, Carol’s challenge forced everyone to recall the actions of Jesus when he was questioned about the woman charged with adultery, and he told her, “Neither do I condemn you. Go, and sin no more”. Looking at Father Dunphy, sitting silently across the room, I wondered what he thought of Carol’s question, and what he would choose to do about the unwed teenager seeking to run for student body office.
In the faculty lounge later that year, I was regaling Carol and Marilyn with stories of living at home with my mom and siblings, and my romantic misadventures in the company of three high school buddies who lived in an apartment near the school. Holding her stomach in laughter, Marilyn gasped that she wanted to meet these bachelor friends, who provided me a haven for continuous juvenile pursuits. As I tried explaining the importance of frivolous recreation, and my cavalier attitude toward dating, Carol suddenly interrupted:
“Tony, there’s a girl we know who I think you should meet”.
“Oh, you mean Kathy”, chimed in Marilyn, cutting short her laughter. “She’s wonderful, and you both have a lot in common.”
The topic immediately sobered me and brought a frown to my face. Working in an environment of nuns, I had become very wary of their matchmaking skills. I didn’t have much confidence in their celibate judgement when it came to predicting romantic chemistry and sexual attraction. I’d seen and met many of their female friends and acquaintances who occasionally visited the school. None of them looked particularly attractive or interesting.
“No thanks, ladies.” I replied gently, not wanting to hurt their feelings.
“It’s not what you think, Tony”, countered Carol. “This girl is different. We’ve known her for a long time, and we really think she’s wonderful”.
“I need you to drop this”, I said firmly and impatiently. “I don’t want to be set-up. I appreciate your interest, but I’m fine – really”.
“We’re not talking about a blind date, Tony”, Marilyn continued. “Kathy is just someone we really like, and we think you would too.”
“Again, thank you ladies, but I’m not interested in meeting anyone. I’m seeing someone right now”. I saw that none of my excuses were having any effect on my determined, religious friends; but when I noticed that Carol was angling for another opportunity to weigh into this debate, I changed tactics.
“Okay, look, I’ll make you a deal. I’ll agree to meet this girl but let me be the one to tell you when. Now is not a good time; but I promise to tell you when I’m ready”.
“You promise?” repeated Carol, warily, looking at Marilyn for support.
“I promise!” I said, raising my right hand as if taking an oath. Reluctantly, Carol and Marilyn took me at my word and accepted the compromise. They dropped the subject and did not raise it again. I was very pleased with myself for having short circuited their designs. I had no intention of ever asking to meet this girl – but I couldn’t forget the promise I made to them.
Two months after this debate with Carol and Marilyn, my relationship with a female teacher at the school ended. The aftermath of this short-lived infatuation lingered far longer than the relationship itself. I entered a dismal, barren period in my life where a meaningful connection with a woman became a ceaseless longing. I had the company of my family at home, friends at school, and three high school buddies, but they were no longer enough. After considerable inner turmoil, I sought out Carol and Marilyn at the lunch table one day and sat next to them.
“Uh, do you remember that conversation we had a while back about a friend you wanted me to meet?” I asked embarrassedly, as the two nuns looked at each other and then me.
“Yes”, they replied in tandem, with secret smiles on their faces.
“Well, I’d like to meet her”, I said. “Just remember, this is not a date. You are just inviting us to dinner along with other people.”
“Okay”, Carol said confidently. “We’ll take care of it”.
The “wonderful” girl Carol and Marilyn wanted me to meet, turned out to be Kathleen Greaney – and they were right. She was nothing I expected. I had visualized a short, mousy-faced graduate student, who would be cautious, demur, quiet, and shy. I assumed all “nun friends” had these qualities (never making the association that I was their friend and yet shared none of them). Kathy was the exact opposite from the “convent girl” I imagined. She had sparkling, hazel eyes, a gorgeous face, and an enchanting, beaming smile. She was tall, with shoulder-length, and sun streaked, dark blonde hair. She glowed with vitality as she exuded humor and laughter. She commanded the dining room and captivated the guests with stories of her family and college experiences. I was totally smitten, and knew I had to see her again. By the end of the evening, I had talked my way into joining the nuns and Kathy on a road trip to Chowchilla, the following day, in support of Cesar Chavez’s farmworker’s grape boycott. At the end of that long and enjoyable day, I took advantage of a moment alone to ask Kathy if I could see her again.
“Sure”, she replied, with a bewitching smile, “that would be great. I’d like that”.
Two years later we were married; with Carol, Marilyn, and the other nuns of their house, as special guests.



Over the years we saw less and less of Carol and Marilyn. They were always invited to large family birthdays and gatherings, but we all pursued different interests, vocations, and moved to different parts of the state. The last time we saw them together, was a visit in 1995 (the date sticks in my mind because it was on the day of O.J. Simpsons’ famous car chase). Yet Carol remained intrinsically tied to us because of our long-lasting friendship and the romantic connection she helped facilitate. I suppose that is how I will remember her. Although I described three memories of Carol, they really coalesce around one central image: Carol was a loving friend – one you could count on for help, solace, guidance, and love. I will miss her and count myself bereft of one more friend of my past.


